Dustin Putman
 This Year

Reviews by Title

Reviews by Year
1997 & previous

Reviews by Rating
4 Star Reviews
3.5 Star Reviews
3 Star Reviews
2.5 Star Reviews
2 Star Reviews
1.5 Star Reviews
1 Star Reviews
0.5 Star Reviews
Zero Star Reviews
Haunted Sideshow

Dustin Putman

Dustin's Blu-ray Review
Lake Placid  (1999)
Reviewed by Dustin Putman

The Film
2.5 Stars
(Release Date: July 8, 2014) – "Lake Placid" is a "creature-in-the-water" thriller with its tongue pressed firmly in cheek. Director Steve Miner (at the time, coming off of 1998's successful "Halloween: H20") apparently has a thing for very short movies—his Michael Myers romp ran a scant 85 minutes, and this one barely makes it to 82—but one positive thing that can be said about their brevity is that they don't have time to wear out their welcome. Further helping things along is David E. Kelley's surprisingly snappy writing, for all intents and purposes transplanting the tone of his hit television show, "Ally McBeal," to the big screen—with crocodiles. Sure, the plot is slimly developed (and ridiculous), but Kelley merely uses the picture's conventional framework as a means of unleashing his colorful, ragtag gaggle of characters.

When a scuba diver is torn in half by something lurking in a seemingly sleepy Maine lake, recently spurned New York paleontologist Kelly Scott (Bridget Fonda) is assigned by her cheating boyfriend/boss (an unbilled Adam Arkin) to travel down to the small town and examine the tooth that was found on the corpse's body. Once down there, she meets up with game warden Jack Wells (Bill Pullman), mythology professor Hector Cyr (Oliver Platt) and two county sheriffs (Brendan Gleeson and Meredith Salenger) to investigate the death. Their ultimate discovery? The culprit is a 30-foot-long crocodile that has leaked in from the ocean, its appetite insatiable enough that it thinks nothing of eating bears, cattle—and humans—at a moment's notice.

"Lake Placid" moves briskly, hopping from its first act to its third with little downtime. The oversized predatory reptile is sometimes animatronic, other times computer-generated, and the effects hold up reasonably well for a mid-budget feature from 1999. If there are the spare shots that are less convincing than others, it is easy to chalk them up to being in the vein of the loopy, all-in-good-fun B-movies which the film appropriately emulates. After all, how else but as a spirited lark can one view a film where a crocodile tries to eat a helicopter?

In the acting department, Bridget Fonda is feisty and resourceful as Kelly, her urban sensibilities comically standing in contrast to her new outdoorsy surroundings. Meanwhile, Bill Pullman is Fonda's token potential love interest, Jack, the two of them flirtatiously sparring with the best of them; Brendan Gleeson plays his bumbling sheriff character to a hilt, and Oliver Platt intentionally goes big—sometimes too big—but garners a handful of laughs in the process. Meredith Salenger, who made a splash in the '80s with such films as "The Journey of Natty Gann" and "Dream a Little Dream," is a welcome face as a local sheriff assigned to the investigation. Last but far from least, the insuppressible Betty White is a scene-stealer as elderly farmer Delores Bickerman, feeding her cows to her wild backyard pet and cheerfully reciting obscene lines like this humdinger: "If I had a dick, this is where I'd tell you to suck it."

Familiar but witty, "Lake Placid" displays an awfully sunny disposition for a film where all manners of severed heads keep getting thrown in Kelly's exasperated direction. To paraphrase a resonant adage from the late, great Roger Ebert, it is less important what a movie is about than how it is about it. Here is a prime example of just that, an old-hat but somehow still fresh horror-comedy that wins its audience over by the personalities onscreen. Yes, Bridget Fonda and Bill Pullman are in a semi-schlocky killer-animal flick, but they are exuberantly drawn characters worth following all the same. It is this certain offbeat charm that has helped "Lake Placid" to improve rather than diminish with age.

Read Dustin's Theatrical Review

Blu-ray Picture/Sound

Studio features hailing from the mid-'90s to early-'00s era often have a specific dated look to them, a result of particular film stocks and lenses of the time period. It is difficult to describe, but high-definition video seems to enhance their images' speckled graininess while doing the best it can with detail-deficient backgrounds. Because "Lake Placid" has this exact aesthetic, it is a tribute to Scream Factory's 1080p transfer that the film nonetheless looks as lively and dynamic as it does. This is an accurate-to-source rendering that, short of a full-blown, frame-by-frame 4K restoration, will likely not look better than it does right here. The print is clean, damage is all but nonexistent, and the bucolic colors of its woodsy lakeside setting are impressively displayed. Only the spare shot briefly appears slightly faded, usually during aerial footage. The 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio is even better, a sturdy, evenly dispersed mix that capably takes advantage of its surround channels during the action interludes. Dialogue is consistently on point. Well done.

Blu-ray Features
  • Making of "Lake Placid" (31:20, HD) – featuring interviews with director Steve Miner, actor Bill Pullman, cinematographer Daryn Okada, editor Marshall Harvey, production designer John Willett, effects superviser Nick Marra and make-up effects supervisor Toby Lindala
  • Vintage Featurette (5:38, HD)
  • Theatrical Trailer (1:58, HD)
  • TV Spots (1:34, HD)
  • Croc Test Footage (7:21, HD)
  • Behind the Scenes Still Gallery (5:31, HD)
Bottom Line
In the fifteen years since its release, "Lake Placid" has only ripened with age. What might have been written off at the time as David E. Kelley slumming it on the big screen now strikes as unusually smart and charmingly quirky. Yes, the film soaks itself in conventions, but Kelley has fun with them and brings a sharply honed comedic edge to his characters and their quick-witted interactions. Scream Factory's Blu-ray release of "Lake Placid" is a little light on bonus content to fall under their "Collector's Edition" umbrella (it's a shame that none of the cast, save for Bill Pullman, chose to participate), but this is still a satisfying package made with care and attention to detail. Fans of the film should not hesitate to pick it up.

Buy Now at Amazon

© 2014 by Dustin Putman
Dustin Putman